Home › Business Services › Insurance broker
The 10 Best Insurance Brokers in Naples (2026)
This list ranks the top insurance brokers in Naples using Google review data and a Bayesian-style score that weights average rating by review volume, updated for 2026. We prioritize businesses that combine strong ratings with a meaningful number of reviews so occasional outliers don’t skew the results. Naples has a mix of year-round homeowners, seasonal residents and coastal risks that influence what people look for in an insurance broker, from home and flood coverage to auto policies. Use this guide as a starting point to compare local firms and narrow down who to contact next.
This ranking is computed from Google reviews (our method). Listings marked Partner are paid advertising spots: they sit alongside the ranking without changing its order.
Are you a insurance broker in Naples?
People reading this page are looking for a pro right now. Put your business above the ranking, with your contact details and a link to your site.
✓ Live immediately · ✓ One-time payment · ✓ No subscription
10 of 10 spots still available
Foxx Insurance Group
Foxx Insurance Group ranks first thanks to a perfect 5.0 Google rating paired with a high review count (1,323), giving it strong statistical weight in our system. Listed as an Insurance broker and located on Tamiami Trail North, its combination of rating and volume is why it tops the list. That balance between score and substantial reviews is what moves it above other highly rated firms.
The full ranking
Progressive Insurance of Florida
Progressive Insurance of Florida appears as an Auto insurance agency with a perfect 5.0 rating across 837 reviews; you’ll find it at 12975 Collier Blvd #109 in the northern Naples area.
837 reviews
Andis Insurance Agency, Inc
Andis Insurance Agency, Inc is rated 5.0 on Google based on 548 reviews and is listed as an Insurance agency on 5951 Pine Ridge Rd in Naples.
548 reviews
Shepherd Insurance | Responsive Insurance
Shepherd Insurance | Responsive Insurance has a 5.0 rating from 323 reviews and is categorized as an Insurance agency located at 2950 Immokalee Rd Ste 4.
323 reviews
Paradise Insurance Agency
Paradise Insurance Agency carries a 5.0 Google score with 275 reviews and is listed as an Insurance agency at 3463 Pine Ridge Rd #101 in Naples.
275 reviews
Galt Insurance Group
Galt Insurance Group holds a 4.9 rating from 1,206 reviews and is listed as an Insurance agency at 900 5th Ave S #201, near the downtown 5th Avenue South corridor.
1206 reviews
Pro America Insurance
Pro America Insurance is shown as a Home insurance agency with a 4.9 Google rating based on 979 reviews; its address is 2352 Pine Ridge Rd in Naples.
979 reviews
Ackerman Insurance Services, Inc.
Ackerman Insurance Services, Inc. has a 4.9 rating from 636 reviews and is listed as an Insurance agency at 1575 Pine Ridge Rd Ste 17.
636 reviews
Jeffrey Bogan: Allstate Insurance
Jeffrey Bogan: Allstate Insurance is rated 4.9 on Google with 520 reviews and operates as an Insurance agency at 2425 Tamiami Trl N Ste 212.
520 reviews
Michael Laskin – State Farm Insurance Agent
Michael Laskin – State Farm Insurance Agent carries a 4.9 rating from 410 reviews and is listed as an Insurance agency at 4099 Tamiami Trl N Ste 305.
410 reviews
Frequently asked questions
How should I choose an insurance broker in Naples?
Look for a combination of solid ratings and a meaningful number of reviews, clear service categories (home, auto, commercial), and familiarity with local risks like coastal exposure. Contact a few brokers to compare coverage options, ask about carrier relationships, and confirm they’re licensed to operate in Florida.
What does it typically cost to use an insurance broker?
Costs vary: some brokers are paid by insurers through commissions, while others may charge fees for advisory services. Ask any broker up front how they are compensated and whether there are additional fees for policy reviews or claims assistance.
What should I check before hiring an insurance broker?
Verify their license status with the Florida insurance regulator, review recent customer feedback, and confirm which carriers they represent. Also ask about experience with policies you need, claims support, and any written terms for advisory or placement services.
How was this ranking built and when should I contact a broker?
The ranking is based on Google review ratings weighted by review counts using a Bayesian-style approach, updated for 2026 to reflect current feedback. Contact a broker when you’re shopping for a new policy, renewing existing coverage, after a life change, or following property purchases or storm damage.