Home › Shops and Services › Thrift store
The 10 Best Thrift Stores in Naples (2026)
Naples offers a varied thrift and consignment scene, from nonprofit resale outlets to small local consignors serving different neighborhoods. This ranking is built entirely from Google reviews and updated for 2026; we used a Bayesian-style weighting that balances average rating with number of reviews so busy, well-liked shops rise to the top. The goal is to reflect both consistency and customer satisfaction rather than unverified claims. Use this guide to compare nearby options for secondhand clothing, homeware, or gifts based on real shopper feedback around Naples. We kept the list strictly data-driven and locally focused.
This ranking is computed from Google reviews (our method). Listings marked Partner are paid advertising spots: they sit alongside the ranking without changing its order.
Are you a thrift store in Naples?
People reading this page are looking for a pro right now. Put your business above the ranking, with your contact details and a link to your site.
✓ Live immediately · ✓ One-time payment · ✓ No subscription
10 of 10 spots still available
Twice As Nice Consignment Shop-North Naples
Twice As Nice Consignment Shop-North Naples takes the top spot with a 4.8 Google rating based on 37 reviews, listed as a consignment shop. Under our Bayesian-style method, that high average combined with a solid review count pushes it ahead of other entries. Its name indicates a North Naples presence, and its score shows consistently strong feedback relative to its review volume. That balance of rating and reviews is why it ranks first in this list.
The full ranking
St. Matthew’s House Golden Gate Thrift Store
St. Matthew’s House Golden Gate Thrift Store carries a 4.7 average from 57 Google reviews and is listed under ‘Thrift store’ in the Golden Gate area.
57 reviews
STARability Studio
STARability Studio has a perfect 5.0 rating based on 15 Google reviews and appears as a gift shop located on 10th Street North in Naples.
15 reviews
Designer Consignor of Naples
Designer Consignor of Naples is listed as a consignment shop with a 4.7 Google rating from 28 reviewers.
28 reviews
Happily Ever After Men & Kid’s Consignment Boutique
51 reviews
Better Bargains, Naples Thrift Store
Better Bargains, Naples Thrift Store holds a 4.6 Google rating from 42 reviews and is listed as a thrift store on Tamiami Trail East.
42 reviews
St. Matthew’s House Parkshore Thrift Store
St. Matthew’s House Parkshore Thrift Store posts a 4.6 average based on 30 Google reviews and is categorized as a thrift store.
30 reviews
St. Matthew’s House Naples Flagship Thrift Store
St. Matthew’s House Naples Flagship Thrift Store is the most-reviewed entry here with 444 Google reviews and holds a 4.4 rating as a thrift store.
444 reviews
Audrey’s Of Naples
Audrey’s Of Naples is listed as a consignment shop and carries a 4.4 Google rating from 166 reviewers.
166 reviews
Twice As Nice Consignment Shop- Downtown
Twice As Nice Consignment Shop- Downtown has a 4.4 average from 153 Google reviews and is categorized as a consignment shop in downtown Naples.
153 reviews
Frequently asked questions
How did you build this ranking?
This list is based on Google review data updated for 2026. We used a Bayesian-style approach that weights the average rating by the number of reviews so that both high scores and meaningful review volume influence rank.
How should I choose a thrift or consignment shop?
Decide whether you want nonprofit thrift bargains, curated consignment pieces, or specialty gift shops, and check recent reviews for consistency on quality and customer service. Location, hours, and the type of items a shop carries are also helpful factors to compare.
What should I check before buying secondhand items?
Inspect items for signs of wear, staining, or damage and test electronics or mechanical pieces when possible. Also ask about return or consignment policies and confirm that any advertised brand labels or sizes match what you expect.
When should I call a thrift or consignment shop?
Call ahead to confirm hours, donation acceptance policies, or whether a store accepts consignments and what their intake process is. It’s also smart to ask about appointment requirements for large donations or high-value items.