Home › Automotive › Tire shop
The 10 Best Tire Shops in Naples (2026)
This list ranks the top tire shops in Naples using a Google-review–based methodology updated for 2026. We order businesses by a Bayesian score that balances average rating with review count, so a well-reviewed, frequently reviewed shop rises above a tiny sample with a perfect score. Naples has a wide mix of options—from quick tire dealers near major corridors to full-service repair shops in residential neighborhoods—so this roundup highlights sites across the city to help drivers, seasonal residents, and visitors alike make a practical choice when they need tires or related auto work.
This ranking is computed from Google reviews (our method). Listings marked Partner are paid advertising spots: they sit alongside the ranking without changing its order.
Are you a tire shop in Naples?
People reading this page are looking for a pro right now. Put your business above the ranking, with your contact details and a link to your site.
✓ Live immediately · ✓ One-time payment · ✓ No subscription
10 of 10 spots still available
A&Y Auto Service LLC / Tires 24 hours/ Llantas
A&Y Auto Service LLC / Tires 24 hours/ Llantas tops our list with a perfect 5.0 Google rating and 123 reviews, giving it strong performance in both score and review volume. The listing is categorized as an Auto repair shop, and the business name suggests a focus on tires and possible round-the-clock availability. Because our ranking weights rating and review count, A&Y’s combination of flawless average and substantial feedback pushes it to the number one spot.
The full ranking
Midas
Midas holds a 4.9 rating backed by 1,323 Google reviews and is categorized as an Auto repair shop, situated on Pine Ridge Road in Naples.
1323 reviews
J&D tires
J&D tires is a 4.9-rated Tire shop with 94 reviews on Google, located on Davis Boulevard in the Davis Blvd area of Naples.
94 reviews
Tire Kingdom
The Tire Kingdom on Tamiami Trail East is listed as a Tire shop and carries a 4.7 Google rating based on 737 reviews, serving the eastern side of Naples.
1332 reviews
Autoworks And Mufflerworks
Autoworks And Mufflerworks appears as a Tire shop with a 4.8 rating and 642 Google reviews, located on Davis Boulevard in the Naples area.
642 reviews
Collier Tire and Auto Repair
Collier Tire and Auto Repair is rated 4.8 with 237 reviews on Google and is listed as a Tire shop near Exchange Avenue in Naples.
237 reviews
The Garage Auto and Tire
Listed as an Auto repair shop, The Garage Auto and Tire has a 4.9 rating from 43 reviews and is located on Pine Ridge Road in Naples.
43 reviews
Performance Truck Tire Inc.
Performance Truck Tire Inc. shows a 4.8 Google rating with 133 reviews and is categorized as a Tire shop on 23rd Avenue SW in Naples.
133 reviews
Collier Goodyear South
Collier Goodyear South is a Tire shop on Collier Boulevard with a 4.7 rating and 926 Google reviews, representing a high-review volume location in Naples.
926 reviews
Tire Kingdom
The Tire Kingdom on Tamiami Trail East is listed as a Tire shop and carries a 4.7 Google rating based on 737 reviews, serving the eastern side of Naples.
737 reviews
Frequently asked questions
How should I choose a tire shop in Naples?
Look at recent customer reviews and the shop’s Google rating, check whether the business is categorized as a tire shop or an auto repair shop, and consider location and hours. Also confirm the shop services the type of tire you need (passenger, truck, specialty) before you visit.
What does it typically cost to replace tires?
Tire replacement cost varies with tire size, brand, and vehicle type, and shops may charge separately for mounting, balancing, and disposal. Get written estimates from a few shops and compare included services to make an informed decision.
What should I check before hiring a tire shop?
Verify the shop’s Google rating and read recent reviews for service quality and reliability, confirm shop hours and availability, and ask about warranties and installation practices. Make sure they use proper equipment for mounting and balancing and keep records of completed work.
How is this ranking built?
The ranking is based on Google review data using a Bayesian-style score that weights average rating by number of reviews, updated for 2026. That method helps balance high averages from small review counts against consistent feedback from busier shops.